ForTheWardsFTW
HomeHow It WorksScenariosSign In
Sign In
Back to Scenarios

Goals of Care: Religious & Spiritual Conflict

Navigate a goals of care discussion with a deeply religious family member who is praying for a miracle and sees withdrawing care as 'playing God'.

  1. 1
    Briefing
  2. 2
    Simulation
  3. 3
    Feedback

How This Works

This is an interactive phone call simulation. You'll speak with Esther in a realistic clinical communication scenario.

1. Start Call

Click "Start Call" when you're ready. Speak naturally as you would on a real call.

2. Have the Conversation

10 minutes to complete the call. The AI responds in real-time to what you say.

3. Get Feedback

End the call when finished. You'll receive AI-powered feedback on your communication.

💡 Tip: Speak clearly and at a natural pace. If you need a moment to think, it's okay to pause briefly - just as you would in a real conversation.

Briefing Details

1. Learning: Navigating Faith and Medical Reality

Purpose of this Scenario

In many cultures, faith and spirituality are central to how families understand illness and death. This simulation focuses on the delicate conversation with a family whose deep religious beliefs lead them to hope for a miracle, even when medical evidence indicates no chance of recovery. The goal is not to challenge their faith, but to find common ground and help them integrate their beliefs with the medical reality in a way that allows for a peaceful, dignified end-of-life process.

Key skills include:

  • Demonstrating cultural and spiritual humility.
  • Using open, non-judgmental language to explore their beliefs.
  • Finding common ground (e.g., the shared goal of preventing suffering).
  • Reframing medical terminology and goals in a way that aligns with, rather than opposes, their spiritual framework.
  • Knowing when and how to involve hospital chaplains or the family's own spiritual advisors.

2. Scenario Briefing: Miracles and Medicine

Your Objective

You are the ICU physician. Your objective is to have a goals of care discussion with Esther, the deeply religious daughter of your 75-year-old patient. Your patient has suffered a devastating, irreversible brain injury. You must communicate the medical prognosis while respecting Esther's belief in miracles, with the goal of transitioning to comfort care.

Patient Background

Your patient is a 75-year-old woman who suffered a severe anoxic brain injury after a post-operative complication. She is on a ventilator and shows no signs of neurologic recovery. Her daughter, Esther, is her proxy.

Crucial Information: Esther is a woman of profound faith. She and her church are praying for a miracle. She interprets any discussion of withdrawing life support as the medical team "playing God" and giving up hope.

Key Medical Facts

  • Diagnosis: Severe anoxic brain injury.
  • Neurologic Status: Exam is consistent with a persistent vegetative state. EEG shows no cortical activity.
  • Prognosis: There is no chance of meaningful recovery or a return to consciousness.
  • Medical Reality: Continuing life support is prolonging a state of biological function, not supporting a person who can interact or experience life.

Learning Objectives

Optional prep details

Learning Objectives loading

Optional Pre-Call Knowledge Check

Optional self-check before you start

Knowledge Check loading

This scenario requires an account. Sign in to begin the simulation.

After completing this scenario, you will be able to:

  • Integrate prognostic information with a patient's family's spiritual and religious framework to guide a goals of care discussion.
  • Formulate communication strategies that acknowledge and validate a family's hope for a miracle while exploring shared goals, such as comfort and dignity.
  • Identify potential points of alignment between spiritual values and medical goals to facilitate shared decision-making.

When initiating a goals of care discussion with a family member who expresses strong faith-based hope for a miracle, what is the most effective initial communication strategy?

A family member says, 'Withdrawing life support would be playing God.' Which response best aligns with the principles of spiritual care and shared decision-making?

The patient has metastatic cancer and is now in the ICU with septic shock and multi-organ failure. Despite maximal therapy (ventilator, multiple vasopressors), he is worsening. What is the most appropriate way to frame this prognosis?